The Fragmented Search Landscape (SEO/AEO/GEO)

At ATRIUM, we’ve seen search evolve faster than most business leaders can reasonably keep up with. The challenge is knowing which changes matter to your business and which can wait. That’s why we asked Chris Lawson, our co-founder, to take 13 minutes to explain how search works today and what that means for the way customers find and evaluate your company.

In the video, Chris explains how SEO, AEO and GEO fit together and shares questions you can bring to your next marketing meeting to better understand where your business stands.

If you’d prefer to read, the full transcript is directly below the video.

The Fragmented Search Landscape

A business can rank number one on Google, maintain its rankings, appear in more searches, and still lose more than half of its clicks.

Not because a competitor passed it.

Not because the website suddenly became worse.

But because the customer received an answer, formed an opinion, and potentially created a shortlist before ever visiting the website.

Search behaviour has fragmented.

My name is Chris Lawson. I am one of the owners of ATRIUM, a digital marketing company that uses Marketing Systems Engineering to help businesses produce more consistent marketing results.

Across the industries we work with, we are seeing a significant change in how customers discover, research, and evaluate companies.

Google is still incredibly important. Traditional search is not disappearing, and SEO is not becoming obsolete.

But Google is no longer the only place where customers search, and a traditional search result is no longer the only place where decisions are influenced.

Customers now move between Google, AI Overviews, maps, review platforms, social media, YouTube, industry websites, and generative platforms such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini.

The more important change is not simply where people are searching.

It is how much of the buying decision can now happen before they reach a company’s website or speak with someone from the business.

And the data is beginning to show us what that means.

Impact of AI Overviews on Clicks

BrightEdge reported that impressions across the content it analyzed increased by more than 49 percent following the expansion of Google’s AI Overviews. At the same time, click-through rates declined by nearly 30 percent.

That means businesses were appearing in more searches but receiving proportionately fewer visits.

Ahrefs found an even larger difference.

Using Google Search Console data across approximately 300,000 keywords, Ahrefs found that when an AI Overview appeared, the average click-through rate for the number-one organic result was approximately 58 percent lower.

The second-ranking result received 51 percent fewer clicks, and the third received 46 percent fewer.

Seer Interactive found a similar pattern in its research across more than 3,100 queries and 42 client organizations. For informational searches containing an AI Overview, organic click-through rates were 61 percent lower in its 2025 findings.

Seer’s subsequent research also showed a partial rebound in early 2026.

That last point matters because this environment is still volatile. These numbers should not be interpreted as a prediction that every company will lose exactly 58 or 61 percent of its traffic.

Different studies use different datasets, industries, queries, and time periods.

But they are identifying the same underlying change.

Rankings, impressions, clicks, and customer discovery are no longer moving together as predictably as they once did.

 

  • A company can rank first and still receive less traffic.
  • A company can increase its impressions and still generate fewer website visits.
  • A dashboard can appear healthy while the customer journey is changing underneath it.

How Generative Systems Interpret Queries

We have seen versions of this across some ATRIUM clients, particularly within healthcare, education, and professional services. Rankings may remain stable or improve while clicks begin moving in the opposite direction.

Again, that does not mean SEO has stopped working.

It means that a ranking now exists inside a much more complicated search experience.

To understand why, it helps to understand what happens behind an AI-generated answer.

In traditional search, someone enters a query and receives a list of results.

A generative system can take one question and interpret it as several related research tasks.

It may look for the type of solution being requested, the user’s location, relevant qualifications, pricing considerations, risks, reviews, alternatives, and evidence supporting each possible recommendation.

It then retrieves useful information from multiple sources, compares that information, and assembles a response.

The user may only ask one question, but the platform can perform several searches and comparisons in the background.

The system is also not limited to retrieving an entire webpage. It may pull a relevant passage, a review, a case study, a business listing, a comparison, a third-party mention, or structured information from several different sources.

This is why having a website is important, but having a website alone is not always enough.

The platform is trying to establish what the business does, who it serves, where it operates, what makes it credible, and whether other sources support those claims.

Then it may move beyond answering a question and begin helping the customer decide which organization appears to be the best fit.

From Keywords to Selection and Fit

That is where the change becomes especially important for business leaders.

A traditional search might begin with:

“Commercial HVAC company Edmonton.”

A generative search could sound more like this:

“We operate a large industrial facility outside Edmonton. Our current system is aging, energy costs are increasing, and we need a company that can assess the existing equipment, complete the work in stages, and provide reliable support afterward. Which companies should we consider, and what questions should we ask them?”

That is not simply a keyword.

It contains the organization’s location, situation, priorities, risks, expectations, and buying criteria.

Now add the context the user may have shared through previous conversations.

Where memory, conversation history, or personalization is enabled, the platform may also have useful context about the user’s organization, budget sensitivity, preferred approach, previous frustrations, internal capabilities, and how they tend to make decisions.

The system does not necessarily provide the same recommendation to everyone.

Two business leaders can ask a similar question and receive different answers because the platform is not only trying to determine who is visible.

It is trying to determine who appears to fit.

  • One user may be directed toward a large national provider.
  • Another may be shown a specialized regional company.
  • Another may receive a list based on technical experience, availability, certifications, price sensitivity, or evidence of working with similar organizations.


This creates an important distinction.

Ranking is about position.

Generative visibility is increasingly about understanding, selection, and fit.

We are also seeing this change appear later in the buyer’s journey.

Across many businesses, AI is becoming more influential during the consideration phase.

Risks of AI Misunderstanding Brands

Prospects are often arriving more educated than before. They have researched terminology, compared options, reviewed possible solutions, and prepared more specific questions before speaking with anyone from the company.

Sometimes that education is useful and accurate.

Sometimes it is incomplete, oversimplified, or simply wrong.

Either way, the prospect’s expectations may have already been shaped.

An AI platform may now participate in the sales conversation before the business knows the prospect exists.

This presents an opportunity, but it also creates risk.

If an AI platform misunderstands the company, it may exclude it from consideration.

If the company’s website contains unclear, incomplete, or outdated information, that information may influence the response.

If competitors are supported by stronger content, clearer service information, better reviews, more credible external mentions, and more consistent business data, the platform may have more evidence available to recommend them.

The company may still rank.

Its website may still receive impressions.

Its existing reports may still appear relatively healthy.

But it may be absent from the part of the customer journey where the shortlist is being created.

SEO, AEO, and GEO Framework

This is why businesses need to understand the relationship between SEO, AEO, and GEO.

  • SEO, or Search Engine Optimization, helps a business become discoverable within traditional search results.
  • AEO, or Answer Engine Optimization, helps the business’s information become eligible for direct answers, featured results, and AI-generated summaries.
  • GEO, or Generative Engine Optimization, helps generative platforms understand, reference, compare, and potentially recommend the business within a user’s specific context.

There is overlap between these areas. They are not three completely separate technical disciplines, and they should not be treated as three disconnected campaigns.

Together, they influence whether a business is found, understood, and selected.

  • SEO helps the customer find the business.
  • AEO helps the business contribute to the answer.
  • GEO helps the business become understood and considered within the customer’s particular situation.


The goal is no longer limited to appearing for a keyword.

The goal is ensuring that search engines and generative platforms can accurately understand:

  • What the company does.
  • Who it serves.
  • Where it operates.
  • What problems it solves.
  • What makes it different.
  • When it is a strong fit.
  • What evidence supports its claims.
  • And whether credible external sources validate what the company says about itself.

Marketing Systems Engineering Approach

At ATRIUM, we approach this through Marketing Systems Engineering, or MSE.

Marketing Systems Engineering looks at how information, routines, platforms, measurement, and business outcomes operate together.

In Search Marketing, this means moving beyond isolated optimizations or one-time website changes.

A strong Search Marketing system requires clear business and service information, useful content, semantic relationships, technical structure, schema, authority signals, reviews, third-party references, distributed content, and recurring measurement.

  • It also requires routines.
  • Business information changes.
  • Customer questions change.
  • Competitors change.
  • Search platforms change.
  • AI-generated answers change.


A company cannot complete one optimization project and assume its visibility is permanently protected.

The system needs to be reviewed, maintained, measured, and improved over time.

This is also a matter of risk management.

If a business depends heavily on one search engine, one advertising platform, one type of content, or one source of leads, a change to that environment can affect the entire marketing system.

Strategic Questions for Business Leaders

The answer is not to abandon Google.

It is not to stop investing in SEO.

And it is not to chase every new AI platform or react to every new statistic.

The answer is to build a more complete and adaptable Search Marketing system.

For business leaders, there are several practical questions worth asking right now.

  1. Are we evaluating rankings alongside clicks, qualified leads, conversions, and revenue?

  2. Can ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Google accurately explain what our business does?

  3. Do we appear when someone asks these platforms to compare providers in our market?

  4. Does our website answer the detailed questions customers ask during consideration?

  5. Are our claims supported by reviews, case studies, industry sources, associations, directories, and other credible third parties?

  6. Are prospects entering sales conversations with assumptions shaped by AI?

  7. And if one major source of traffic or leads declined, would the rest of our marketing system continue producing opportunities?

  8. These questions are more useful than asking whether SEO is dead or whether AI will replace Google.

SEO remains foundational.

But SEO now operates inside a broader environment that includes answer engines, generative platforms, maps, reviews, video, external sources, and increasingly personalized recommendations.

A growing number of ATRIUM clients have added Search Marketing routines to their broader marketing systems.

Some are focused on protecting the visibility they already have.

Some are preparing for AI-driven discovery.

Some want to reduce their dependence on paid traffic or a single source of leads.

Others see an opportunity to build authority and gain market share while competitors are still determining how to respond.

Adapting to AI-Driven Discovery

If you are a current ATRIUM client and want to understand how these changes may affect your business, let your Project Coordinator know, and we will connect you with the appropriate team member.

If you are new to ATRIUM, contact our team and we can examine how your company currently appears across traditional search, direct answers, and generative platforms.

But regardless of whether you speak with ATRIUM, begin by examining how your customers actually research and evaluate companies like yours.

Ask new customers where they first discovered you.

Listen for references to ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, AI Overviews, Reddit, YouTube, reviews, and other sources that may not receive proper credit in your reporting.

  1. Compare rankings with actual clicks, leads, and revenue.
  2. Test whether generative platforms understand your company accurately.
  3. And identify how dependent your growth is on any single source of visibility.


The companies in the strongest position will not necessarily be the ones chasing every new platform or reacting to every headline.

They will be the ones building credible information, strong authority, diversified visibility, and repeatable marketing routines that can adapt as customer behaviour changes.

Search behaviour has fragmented.

The objective now is not simply to rank.

It is to be found, understood, and selected.

Explore ATRIUM’s approach to search marketing to see how SEO, AEO and GEO work together. If the video raised questions about where your business shows up when customers compare providers, talk to our team about what you’re seeing and where to focus next.

Share On

Atrium Digital